Clip review and handoff form
On this page
Reviewer identity / role / timestamp: [record]
Independent of maker: [yes/no; self-review is valid when labelled]
Candidate ID/version/hash / canon / packet / neighbours: [pins]
Review coverage: full motion [yes/no]; audio listened [yes/no]; frame sampling [exact times]; metadata [checks].
Rubric name/version/source: [provisional workflow rubric or verified named source]
| Test ID | Required? | Expected result | Observed result / source or timecode | Pass / fail / unverified / N/A |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ID] | [yes/no] | [criterion] | [evidence] | [status; explain N/A] |
Hard gates: story outcome, identity/props/geography, readable physics, start/end state, picture/audio, delivery requirements. Every applicable hard gate must pass.
Ratings: story / continuity / performance / camera-editability / sound / technical, each 0–4 with evidence. Never average away a hard failure.
Usable source interval / timeline location: [start/end in seconds, end exclusive]
Outgoing boundary: [actual frame and complete state]
Verdict: [candidate usable / revision required / rejected / unverified]; creative acceptance remains a separate DR decision.
Four review lanes
Creative: [story/message clarity, performance, composition, rhythm and intended feeling; timecodes]
Continuity: [identity, props, geography, direction, light and sound state; allowed transitions]
Technical: [frame/motion integrity, readable text, sync and destination requirements]
Rights/release: [source/voice/music/likeness evidence, applicable accessibility and unresolved conditions]
Previous and following join: [actual motion and sound review; opening/ending may replace an absent neighbour]
A plausible cause is a hypothesis. Test whether the issue comes from the reference, staging, missing coverage, edit timing or sound before choosing the smallest repair. Do not generate coverage merely because a table suggests it if an intentional omission or existing trim serves the approved meaning.
Targeted revision request
Finding ID / severity / failing interval: [record]
Expected / observed / likely cause / uncertainty: [record]
Smallest repair / owner / pinned inputs / test to close finding: [record]
Affected neighbours and downstream artifacts: [list]
Other shots sharing this root cause checked: [scope/result]
Remaining cumulative time / attempts / cost / fallback: [record]